Overclockers Australia Forums
OCAU News - Wiki - QuickLinks - Pix - Sponsors  

Go Back   Overclockers Australia Forums > Specific Hardware Topics > Extreme and Water Cooling

Notices


Sign up for a free OCAU account and this ad will go away!
Search our forums with Google:
Reply
 
Thread Tools
Old 9th December 2009, 10:26 PM   #1
bundymania Thread Starter
Member
 
bundymania's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: -=- German Reviewer -=-
Posts: 583
Lightbulb REVIEW: SIZE MATTERS - Radiators for 140mm Fans - Big Roundup

(translated by Google, so beware of some errors )




Hello friends of the wet element,


in fact, one could advance already come to the following conclusion: The size is still important!
Now, however, the technique is essential, otherwise all the radiators of this test would be on a level of performance.
But first things first: As the reader has already been easily noticed, is what this review to the new
Power superclass of the heat exchanger, namely internally for sheeting radiators, for the increasingly popular 140mm fan! This fact is in a relatively quieter background noise while maintaining good cooling performance as the previously
so popular for 120mm fan radiators founded. As a rough rule of thumb one can say: A rad fitted with 3 x 140mm radiator fans of the new generation is about the power of a Quadradiator, which is designed for 4 x 120mm fans. Since many case manufacturers have already for some time for 140mm fan designed models in the portfolio,
It was only a matter of time, until you can buy suitable heat exchanger for this increase in performance.
As the demands and desires of the users are very diverse, I have decided to not only one size in
take my test box, but take into account almost all available Radiators for the big fan of!


Speaking test field, the ranks of the radiator to be tested are joined by the following models:








Hardware Labs Black Ice SR1 280






Technical details:

Dimensions: 315 x 54 x 153 mm (WxHxD)
Material: Copper, brass
Color: Black
Weight: 1.09 kilograms
Connections: 2x G1 / 4 inches
Fan Compatibility: 2x 140 mm
Fan Mounting: M4 threaded (both ends)
Price: about EUR 105





HW Labs Black Ice SR1 420







Technical details:

Dimensions: 459 x 54 x 153 mm (WxHxD)
Material: Copper, brass
Color: Black
Weight: 1.5 kilograms
Connections: 2x G1 / 4 inches
Fan Compatibility: 3x 140 mm
Fan Mounting: M4 threaded (both ends)
Price: about EUR 135




HW Labs Black Ice SR1 560












Technical details:


Dimensions: 604 x 54 x 153 mm (WxHxD)
Material: Copper, brass
Color: Black
Weight: 1.94 kilograms
Connections: 2x G1 / 4 inches
Fan Compatibility: 4x 140 mm
Fan Mounting: M4 threaded (both ends)
Price: about EUR 180





The company's hardware labs for many years successfully established and offers a wide selection of high quality radiators
in many sizes and variations. One feature distinguishes this from all the models: The workmanship is first class!
The new SR1 Radis are, fortunately for both 120mm and 140mm fan available from single-to Quadradiator.
So far, Black Ice Radiators have been due to their dense fin density rather rapidly rotating fan beyond 800 rpm. optimized and were able to heat from other manufacturers in Europe, especially in the popular low revs hard to argue in comparative tests. This event can now be safely placed with the SR1 series on the file, because with this new radiator series hardware labs now promising products brought to market, which were also optimized, especially for less air flow! A peculiarity is the different distance from the fan blades: On the side without
The two threaded connection is down this much larger, which represents a kind of shroud, ie the dead center under the
Fan hub is significantly reduced, which leads to better overall performance! Of course I have the fans on both sides
assembled to determine the differences. On the page with "Shroud" stood a better fan speed according to the Delta-T
Value of max. 0.7-up! In my results tables, I have both the best value, ie, with assembly on the "Shroudside" is used.
Like the 480s SR1 Radi, can convince even the models for 140mm. The performance is very good and are processed by the
there is currently nothing better on the radiator market.
The SR-1 series white at first glance like: the matte black finish is flawless, all threads have been immaculately produced, and the fins have turned out very coarse meshed, so as mentioned below is ideal for slow-spinning fans and accordingly noise! For this test, I was kindly of SR1 560 and SR1 280 of the company www.caseking.de sent. The SR1 420 Model I got from www.ac-shop.de provided.
My thanks goes also to Mr. Wilbert Yuque from hardware labs.







Thermochill PA 140.3 Triple Radiator














Specifications:

- Color: matte black
- G 3 / 8 "connectors
- Tank: brass; fins: copper
- Weight: about 1.82 kilograms
- Dimensions (LxWxH): 480 x 142 x 62mm
- Price: about EUR 110




Almost as a living legend, one could describe the radiators in the UK-based company Thermo Chill.
In the past, many test victories worldwide have been retracted, but there were also some points for improvement.
The finish was sometimes left to be desired at times and some users reported by impurities in the interior, which
during flushing of new Rads came to light. Other features of the thermal radiators Churchill are the two connecting thread,
which runs in more exotic G 3 / 8 "thread adapter, and can therefore be in most cases a necessity.
Furthermore, the so-called hole size for the fan was slightly larger than that of heat exchangers of the competitors, so that one normal
Not able to use radiator panels for the Case integration and was dependent on specific panels.
The finish is with my pattern out to be much better than it used to in the TC Rads was the case and offers
no reason for complaint.
At the held in the English language leaflets to rinse with warm water before first use is recommended to
to liberate the Rad of any production residues. It was struck directly at the first flush or almost clear water
from 140.3 to appear, even at this point was thus improved compared to older models of anything!
The 420s Rad from the house can convince Thermo Chill completely in this test of the performance and can be the first place in
This radiator size to win for themselves! The only downer at the moment poor availability in Germany was
mentioned but in neighboring countries, fortunately, these models during www.highflow.nl and www.it-service.be available!








Magicool Slim Dual 280 MC








Specifications:

Material: Copper, brass auricles
Dimensions: (L x W x H): 323x142x29mm
Connections: G1 / 4 "
Weight: about 646g
Mountability: from both sides for fan or as a holder
Airtight: 8 bar
Connection: 2x thread G 1 / 4 inch
Fan connecting thread: M3
Price: about EUR 42




Magicool Slim Triple 420 MC








Specifications:

Material: Copper, brass auricles
Dimensions: (L x W x H): 465x142x29mm
Connections: G1 / 4 "
Weight: about 860g
Mountability: from both sides for fan or as a holder
Airtight: 8 bar
Connection: 2x thread G 1 / 4 inch
Fan connecting thread: M3
Price: about EUR 58



The Magicool radiators out of the house are known for their good performance at a relatively low price. Here and there
may miss a thread not be ok, but this one takes as preisleistungsbewusster buyers like to purchase. Also in
This test can convince the models of Magicool. From the performance for many applications and has sufficient
3 sizes available. Due to the low mounting depth can the Radis platsparend and unobtrusively in many housing
. integrate On the housing market have been some housing available in the Model 280s without the modifications
to assemble, more will surely follow soon.







TFC Monsta Lite 420/360 Radiator








From TFC - The Feser Company reached me the prototype of a Monsta Lite radiator.
Prototype because of possible changes to the final retail version, which is positive for
can affect the performance! The radiator should be out in spring of 2010 with a retail price of approximately EUR 150
in the trade as already come and get the big brother with a comprehensive package accordingly.
Thanks to a clever craftmanship there can be mounted both 120mm and 140mm fan, this option so far is unique
on the radiator market! Furthermore, the usual 2 G 1 / 4" threaded 2 additional threads on the front
the TFC Monsta Lite available, which one at about 10 liters of increased flow and a greater variety
The tubing of the heat exchanger brings with it!
Even though the "little monster" of the performance is not quite the best in this test field radiators
could catch up, so the whole concept could convince yet and is already as large Monsta
Radiator will find its fans worldwide!


you can extract the technical data from this PDF File:

http://www.tfc-xchanger.com/pdf/TFC-X420L.pdf



Last but not least, and virtually not competing, I have one as a comparison Dualradiator included in the test with





Specifications:
Material: Copper, brass auricles
Dimensions: (L x W x H): 273x121x30mm
Connections: G1 / 4 "
Weight: about 680g
Mountability: 8x M3 threaded top (for 2x 120mm fan), 8x M3 threaded bottom (for 2x120mm fan)
Airtight: 8 bar
Connection: 2x thread G 1 / 4 inch
Hole distance: 6 cm
Price: about EUR 29



Testsystem / Process:






Case: Banchetto 101 Bench Table
Board: Gigabyte GA-EX58-Extreme
CPU: Intel Core i7-920 @4.2Ghz - 1,40V (Bios Setting) - Bios: F4
RAM: Patriot Viper DIMM Kit 6GB PC3-12800U CL8-8-8-24
Gfx card: EVGA GTX 295 (not included for this comparison!)
Netzteil / PSU: Xilence SPS-XP850.XQ.R2
CPU Waterblock: Watercool Heatkiller 3.0 Nickel Edition
NB Waterblock: Mips Fusionblock
Control Unit: Aquaero VFD
Flow Sensor: Aqua Computer Highflow
Thermal Compound: Gelid Extreme
Pump: Laing Ultra (Koolance PMP400 Deckel)
Pump Noise Absorber: Noise Destructor V1.1
Tubing: Feser/DD 16/10mm
2x CPC 9,5mm Metal
Ausgleichsbehälter: Alphacool Cyclone 250
Tempsensors: 3x Inline +1x in Res.
Wasserzusatz: Feser One Fertigmischung UV Clear/Blue
Fittings: Perfect Seal + Bitspower
Fans used: Noiseblocker Black Silent Pro PK2 + PK3 (PL2 on Magicool Slim 240)



To fill the CPU is Prime95 (small FFT's) used in the latest version, to measure the
Temperatures / record came aquasuite used. The temperature measurements were made after the earliest
60 min and then in 5 intervals, a 5 minutes.

In my testing, the most interesting value of the difference (delta T) is the temperature of water at the outlet of the radiator. This figure shows the cooling capacity of the radiator, into which you can see, can take advantage of how well the radiator to cool the inside temperature of the water. The smaller this difference turns out, the stronger the performance of the radiator. The results will be visible to the interested user at a glance, so I will confine myself in addition to the flow of that value in the different fan speeds.























Difference (delta T) from room temperature to water temperature)
(a low score is better)










Flowrate



Liter / hour




Conclusion:


80mm fan in the case sector were until a few years, Standard, this was followed by the hitherto popular 120mm fans
and so it is really just a matter of time until those from the 140mm previously rather rarer still used by representatives of its
Species to be replaced. More and more manufacturers are adopting this fan size and rightly so. In this test, the radiators
has been shown that the development goes on, fortunately more power and less noise. During
all sorts of annoying noises of everyday life, this is very commendable, they nevertheless give latest processors and graphics cards quietly
and cool more effectively. A clear recommendation for a radiator model could be due to different needs and requirements
not naturally inclined to express the water cooler. In the upper performance range Thermo Chill and Hardwarelabs have
impressively demonstrated, where the bar is located at radiator of this size at this time. The heat exchanger can be of Feser
equip themselves with fans conveniently in 2 sizes, advantageous for many around and intermediates, which are the costs of
Save the purchase of new 140mm fans want first. Are a good idea at this point, the additional threads
called at the front of the radiator. As might be expected to have the Magicool Rads again as price-performance
assert winner in this test. Here and there a thread was not cut 100% and the build quality is noticeably
behind the Black Ice SR1 series, but due to the comparatively low price and the offered services, these radiators
definitely worth a recommendation for the budget-conscious users. Who the best synthesis of performance and outstanding
Processing is looking, just come by to SR1 radiators manufacturer Hardwarelabs not. Very impressive is especially
Proved 560s exchanger, which means pure performance. High-end PC systems with 2 video cards can be with this model
cool very well - the performance has to be even before that of a Mora 2 Pro's Monsterradis not hide!
One can only wonder what will bring us this 140mm radiators and other manufacturers in the future,
a very good beginning has been made! Hardwarelabs was sort of a pioneer, as far as radiators in this size, so
the GT and GTX versions available for some time. As these models, primarily for high-speed and high Fans
Air flow shall be designed, I did not apply to voting in this test.
If available, I will review these with other radiators for complementary 140mm fan!





Many Thanks for supporting my Review goes to the following companies:


www.a-c-shop.de , www.alphacool.com , www.mips-computer.de , www.caseking.de , www.magicool.biz, www.feser-one.com , www.gelidsolutions.com , www.laing.de , www.hardwarelabs.com , www.watercool.de , www.thermochill.com , www.highflow.nl , www.it-service.be , www.xilence.de , www.noiseblocker.de
bundymania is offline   Reply With Quote

Join OCAU to remove this ad!
Old 10th January 2010, 11:09 AM   #2
Agg
Lord of the Pings
 
Agg's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: A Reported Post near you
Posts: 26,561
Default

I'm surprised nobody has commented on this. Thanks for the nice article.
__________________
www.overclockers.com.au - also now on twitter and facebook.
Agg is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10th January 2010, 11:16 AM   #3
n3wbi379
Member
 
n3wbi379's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Melb
Posts: 4,525
Default

wowwwwwwwwwwwww nice round up ......
__________________
One Awsome Day Out - CLICK
n3wbi379 is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 10th January 2010, 12:52 PM   #4
wookiie
Member
 
wookiie's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Western Sydney
Posts: 662
Default

Great review.........good job
wookiie is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10th January 2010, 1:07 PM   #5
Ckool
Member
 
Ckool's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Liverpool,Sydney
Posts: 106
Default

Awesome job ..
__________________
Lian Li pc p80r|PhenomIIx4 965|CrosshairIII|2 x Powercolor 5970|Intel X25-M 160GB G2| Corsair Dominator GT PC3-16000 C8 8GB| Thermaltake ToughPower 1500W|Dell 3008|Windows7 Ultimate
EK-Multioption Reservoir 400 Rev2|EK-FB ASUS Crosshair 3 Black Acetal+Nickel|XSPC RX360 Radiator|EK-FC 5970 Acetal+Nickel|EK-Supreme HF Acetal|EK Dual top
Ckool is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10th January 2010, 1:37 PM   #6
WuzzA21
Member
 
WuzzA21's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,230
Default

Wow, I know what I'm going to get for my next rad. One of those black ice 560 rads.
__________________
W3540 | EVGA e760 | 7990 | 12GB Patriot Viper 2 2000MHz | 2x Vortex 3's, 1x OS 240gb and 1x GAMES 120gb | RAID1 2x WD 1TB Caviar Black | TJ07 | Corsair AX850w MDPC-X
HF | BI GTX 480 | EK NB SB | EK-DDC Dual TOP V.2 | EK 7990 Block | EK Monarch X6 | STEALTH 175 RES
WuzzA21 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10th January 2010, 2:02 PM   #7
converge
Member
 
converge's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Melbourne, 3806
Posts: 2,298
Default

thanks for that bundy. just need to find a case to fit those 140mm rads in.
__________________
Project: Jane Doe | Project: TYR | Project: Killer Penguin

Project: Killer Penguin 2.0

Lian Li V600FX | ASUS R4G | i7 3820 @ 5Ghz H20 | HD 7970 H20 | Mushkin 16GB Redlines | Intel 330 180GB | Seasonic CP860W Custom Sleeved | Watercooled by Watercool Heatkiller
converge is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 10th January 2010, 4:34 PM   #8
Trog Star
Member
 
Trog Star's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Blue Mountans, NSW
Posts: 948
Default

no reference to fan RPM?

um, thats kinda important
Trog Star is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10th January 2010, 6:49 PM   #9
WuzzA21
Member
 
WuzzA21's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,230
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Trog Star View Post
no reference to fan RPM?

um, thats kinda important
Umm u/min is RPM... He did mention that it was translated by google and that there would be some things that would not make sence.
__________________
W3540 | EVGA e760 | 7990 | 12GB Patriot Viper 2 2000MHz | 2x Vortex 3's, 1x OS 240gb and 1x GAMES 120gb | RAID1 2x WD 1TB Caviar Black | TJ07 | Corsair AX850w MDPC-X
HF | BI GTX 480 | EK NB SB | EK-DDC Dual TOP V.2 | EK 7990 Block | EK Monarch X6 | STEALTH 175 RES
WuzzA21 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 22nd January 2010, 3:05 PM   #10
Spork!
Member
 
Spork!'s Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Tasmania
Posts: 1,717
Default

Interesting. Am I correct in saying there was only 1 x 120mm (fans) rad in there - and a cheap nasty one @ that... Would be good to see some better, thicker, 2-3 and 4 x 120mm rads compared to the 140mm ones. I'm sure the 140mm will still be better, but possibly not by so much.
__________________
http://yrbrutsapussy.mybrute.com | E5200 @ 3.837, Q6600 @ 3.33 (3.75 bench), Q9650 @ 3.7 - 1.2625 vCore
http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/lr8zwg-3.png
Spork! is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23rd January 2010, 7:35 PM   #11
ugoh2o
New Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Southern BrisVegas
Posts: 10
Default

Thanks!
This is the first review I have seen that makes a decent comparison with a nice roundup of 140mm fan radiators.
And @Spork: yes, there is only 1 120mm radiator in there, but I think you can only really compare it to it's 140mm Magicool brother.
A couple more 120's in this roundup would have been great, but I'm already very happy with this.
ugoh2o is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 23rd January 2010, 11:24 PM   #12
JTF
Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Brisbane 4118
Posts: 561
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Spork! View Post
Interesting. Am I correct in saying there was only 1 x 120mm (fans) rad in there - and a cheap nasty one @ that... Would be good to see some better, thicker, 2-3 and 4 x 120mm rads compared to the 140mm ones. I'm sure the 140mm will still be better, but possibly not by so much.
Measuring the surface area of the PA140.3 it is a little larger than the PA120.4, so presuming the same airflow it should perform a little better too, should also have a slightly better coolant flow rate too, the 140 having a few more, shorter tubes...
__________________
Evga SR-2, 2 x 5620 @ 3.8, 2 x GTX480, all H20 cooled.
JTF is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 24th January 2010, 1:38 AM   #13
OldnBold
Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Canberra
Posts: 4,097
Default

Good comprehensive review thanks
__________________
ASUS Owners Club
OldnBold is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 24th January 2010, 1:28 PM   #14
Trog Star
Member
 
Trog Star's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Blue Mountans, NSW
Posts: 948
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by WuzzA21 View Post
Umm u/min is RPM... He did mention that it was translated by google and that there would be some things that would not make sence.
ah.
now it's quite a nice roundup

well done
Trog Star is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 7th February 2010, 9:25 PM   #15
-Cypher-
(Banned or Deleted)
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Adelaide
Posts: 930
Default

Does anybody know whether the Koolance HX-CU-1403V is the same as the Magicool Slim 420mm? They look really similar in pictures-

http://www.koolance.com/water-coolin...product_id=964

Looks like a pretty decent rad considering it's slim profile, I'm considering getting one for the bottom of my RV02 (with some BlackSilentPros or Thermalright 140mm perhaps)
-Cypher- is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Sign up for a free OCAU account and this ad will go away!

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +10. The time now is 6:13 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd. -
OCAU is not responsible for the content of individual messages posted by others.
Other content copyright Overclockers Australia.
OCAU is hosted by Internode!