Download Managers – A Review for x64 platforms

Discussion in 'General Software' started by phoenix_advance, Jun 7, 2007.

  1. phoenix_advance

    phoenix_advance Member

    Joined:
    Mar 28, 2004
    Messages:
    272
    Location:
    Melbourne
    Review Date/Links last valid at: Thursday 7th June 2007, 3:30 PM (GMT+10:00)

    Preface:

    Why do we need download managers? Maybe if we lived in a country where the amount we downloaded wasn’t that precious, we wouldn’t care (points his finger to Telstra). The reality is of course though we’ve had that odd power failure, BSOD and disconnection from our ISP...

    Procedure (until a good Download Manager is found):

    Install with recommended settings and run. Configure options for simplicity of use. Download a 1 MB file. Download a file greater than 200MB. Clean Up Registry. Retry Software. Uninstall. Clean Up Registry.

    Software Setup:
    • Windows OS – Vista x64
    • Web Browser – Internet Explorer x64
    • Security Setup – Router Firewall and Internet Options – Pretty damn “High”
    Outcomes/What "I'm" Looking For:

    If a program comes up with a single error, it will have the shortest review you’ll ever see. Let’s face it, when we download a massive file from a link we catch from browsing web sites (whether it be an application or demo of an upcoming game) we just want to right-click and have it saved to a folder of our choice! No other BS! Download speed will not really be an issue so long as it provides according to your ISP plan’s specs. Not interested in FTP, Browsing, Torrents and other features.

    Rank #1: Free Download Manager 2.1 (FDM)

    Believe it or not, but this was the second last program I tried out. Why? Because it’s free! And technically nothing is really free. You’d expect some kind of harsh treatment like adware or spyware. But surprisingly, this program doesn’t seem to have any (MSN Messenger seems more dangerous).

    Installation is easy with no reboot required. Customisation of options goes such a long way, which shows great flexibility without clutter. For my purposes, I did have to customise nevertheless. All in all, you couldn’t ask for more from a free program!

    Rank #2: Internet Download Manager 5.0.9.5 (IDM)

    This was the second program I trialled out. It’s not a free application which is a major negative (who’d want to buy a download manager, really?) So what are you paying to get out of this program that you can’t get with FDM? The answer is nothing!

    Installation is a bit of a hassle with a reboot required (uninstall). More than normal amount of errors after uninstall and clean up of the registry. The customisations are a little cluttered but nowhere close to or below mediocre standard. It seems to be the fastest (by only a few kilobytes). GUI looks Windows 98ish ugly!

    Rank #3: Download Accelerator Plus v8.5 Premium (DAP)

    This program sort of works ... good news is that there is a free version; bad news is that there is a premium version with more features that you have to pay for. Initially I had to ask myself if the “Extreme” speed download option really did anything. I don’t think so. Bad customisation of options and bad GUI interface cluttered with web browsing BS! Seriously, why would I want to know the top files that other people are downloading (Messenger 8, eMule, Google Earth ... Bah, Meh, Psst ...)? In addition I’m pretty sure I personally encountered an error that rendered the program useless.

    Rank #4: NetTransport 2.40 Vista

    I was very disappointed with NetTransport. I’ve used one of their free versions (version 1.something) since Windows ME. It was one of those install and forget programs. Use to be great. Still feels great with a fresher GUI and once again not having to fiddle with the options after installing. I think this had the least amount of errors in the registry after uninstall. But unfortunately this version didn’t seem to work at all! Must be an x86 only thing :(

    Rank #5: GetRight 6.2a

    Well ... it installs ... and looks ugly ... (right-click browser context menu script error)

    Rank #6: HiDownload 6.99

    Well ... it installs ... and looks pretty ... (right-click browser context menu script error)

    Rank #7: LeechGet 2007 Release 2000

    This was the very last program I tried out. I gave it a shot for reviewing sake and to see whether it was any better than FDM (since LeechGet is also free for private use). Tons of errors after uninstall and clean up of registry. Options feel limited and alas, I cannot download a file when using its download option in the browser context menu ... (script error)

    Conclusion:

    Yeah I’m pretty sure there are other download managers I haven’t tried that are worth having a go at. But these are the main one’s that came across my path when looking for the right one. Whilst I’m pretty sure each of these Download Managers works on an OS like Windows XP SP2 flawlessly (yes I have tested most and they work) ... the only and clear winner for an x64 system is the FDM.
     
    Last edited: Jun 7, 2007
  2. whisp

    whisp (Banned or Deleted)

    Joined:
    Jul 10, 2005
    Messages:
    409
    i use flashget http://www.flashget.com/en/download.htm


    the best FREE download manager imo

    FlashGet is specifically designed to address two of the biggest problems when downloading files: Speed and management of downloaded files. If you've ever waited forever for your files to download from a slow connection, or been cut off mid-way through a download - or just can't keep track of your ever-growing downloads - FlashGet is for you. FlashGet can split downloaded files into sections, downloading each section simultaneously, for an increase in downloading speed from 100% to 500%. This, coupled with FlashGet's powerful and easy-to-use management features, helps you take control of your downloads like never before FlashGet support HTTP,HTTPS,FTP,MMS,MMST,RTSP ,BT protocol

    Im running this on vista x64 with out any problems what so ever!...iv tryed quiet a few getright, etc but this always comes up trumps and it supports so much its awsome!
     
    Last edited: Jul 15, 2007
  3. killer65210

    killer65210 Member

    Joined:
    May 3, 2004
    Messages:
    304
    Location:
    Drummoyne, NSW
    Good write up mate. Im using FDM myself and have been for about 21 mths without a single error. Its been great.

    Leechget is a disapointment. the 2004 edition was great but upgrading limited the capabilities and meant that you had to upgrade just to have the same performance as FDM.
     
  4. porridge

    porridge New Member

    Joined:
    Feb 25, 2004
    Messages:
    890
    Location:
    Sydney
    I just use firefox's download manager these days. Can pause and resume and works for mefine.
    All the download managers I have used in the past didnt really seem to give me any faster downloads. That being said I never used a bought version where they supply multiple mirrors at once.
     
  5. Aetherone

    Aetherone Member

    Joined:
    Jan 15, 2002
    Messages:
    8,514
    Location:
    Adelaide, SA
    I'd recommend you have a look at "wackget" which is simply a GUI for the venerable wget.
    It's very basic (somewhat lacking in features) but its tiny in both size and memory footprint, super clean on your system and works great here. Interestingly even thought its supplied as an installer, you can just copy the folder around the place (all 317kb of it & yes to new windows installs) and run the program just fine.

    I love it, its great :thumbup:
     
  6. Semi-Evolved

    Semi-Evolved Member

    Joined:
    Aug 11, 2003
    Messages:
    7,089
    Location:
    Brisbane
    When the file's too big to trust to Firefox, wget does the job just fine for me. Personally, most of my downloads from http/ftp are straight from my ISP's mirrors, and download at ~1mb/s. There's simply no advantage for me in using a download manager for most files when the files aren't counted towards my usage and they download that quickly.
     
  7. Utetopia

    Utetopia Member

    Joined:
    Jun 18, 2004
    Messages:
    2,647
    Location:
    BNE/TWMBA
    Getright worked well for me when I was on dial-up. Very simple to use. Only HTTP for free version. FTP costs.
     
  8. Michael H

    Michael H Member

    Joined:
    Feb 26, 2002
    Messages:
    905
    IDM works a treat under Windows XP 32bit.
     
  9. dean_is_not

    dean_is_not Member

    Joined:
    Apr 10, 2003
    Messages:
    829
    Location:
    Queensland
    I usually just use downthemall which is a firefox addon. Works fine, can have up to 10 chunks going at once. Plus it's small and uses pretty much no resources.
     

Share This Page