Discussion in 'Business & Enterprise Computing' started by Xpfan47, Jul 31, 2018.
what if i want to name my servers after their ipv6 address?
or a phone number
0118 999 881 999 119 7253
Hostnames are not supposed to replace AAAA records
why can't they be the same?
it would certainly make things easier if there was an issue with DNS and you needed to know the IP address of a host.
oh yeah, tell me about your proposed nomenclature for dev/uat/prod - country/cloud - state/region - function/purpose/ID
15 chars due to 1980's netbios half baked scale thoughts that seem to mirror your suggestion, hey IPv4 is enough also right?
Well, for Dev, I name physical servers after their asset tags, and virtual servers have a GUID, all of the metadata is stored in a CMDB.
for uat, I name physical servers after their asset tags, and virtual servers have a GUID, all of the metadata is stored in a CMDB.
but for prod, I name physical servers after their asset tags, and virtual servers have a GUID, all of the metadata is stored in a CMDB.
(Production-Australia-Queensland-File Server-1) - 15 characters
(Production-%country code-State Area code-File Server-1)
(Development-Australia-Northern Territory-SQL Server-1
Again find a naming convention that suits the limitation.
Let someone use:
TestingProductionServerToReplaceTheCurrentFileServer and they will.......
Instead use an OS that doesn't mandate this draconian limitation
I've got more than 9 file servers in Queensland.
We bitch at users for using directory and file names for storing metadata.
But we advocate using hostnames to store metadata.
Sometimes, I really don;t understand us.
case in point
clear and easy, Windows would require you create new child subdomains, Domain Controllers populating faster than rabbits.
Pardon the pedantry, but does a 2-letter SDLC gain you anything a 1-letter wouldn't?
PD vs P, DV versus D. Do you reach a collision state otherwise?
I previously worked somewhere with Dev, UAT, Prod, Support. A single letter for each designation was plenty.
Similarly, hyphens add a lot of characters there too. Perhaps easier to read for humans, but if your hostname characters are precious, then they're precious.
Actually, disregard everything I've said. I'm with him.
I worked years ago for a place that agreed all server names were bullshit. They ended up with "body parts" for server names (all clean and work safe, mind you). "knuckles", "foot", "knee", "elbow" were all servers. Pre-virtualisation, however, so over the course of their lives they'd do different things as tasks moved to and fro. Was an interesting concept at the time, although probably would have fallen apart in a larger business.
Not at all, I was just trying to prove that you can achieve the outcome with a 15 character limit if you have a standard naming convention in place.
It makes it harder for me to come up with rude server names... like calling the DBA's developement machine DVDA1
Just five folks having a good time.
just because we make the rules, doesn't mean we have to follow them.
Used to work in a place where the first letter of the server name was it's function, but otherwise, they were anything you wanted. Made for interesting times.
Using AAA-AAA-000 in the format of 3letter location, 3 letter usage, 3 digit number. Used for ilo, esx, nas, san, servers, pos, workstations etc., everything gets it.
Definitely no recycling of host names as the app vendors are f*cking useless and if I reuse them something really stupid and avoidable will happen
I call all my servers 123456
saves confusion - easy to find.
My last place was like that.
2 letter region, 3 letter site code, 2 letter device type, 3 digit number.
Before that it was
Which was the same as above but the first 2 letters were less accurate for the region
Before that it was
3 letter company abbreviation, 2 letter site code, 2 letter device code, 3 digit number.
Those changes happened over the course of my 10 years at that place. By the end of my 10 years all three naming schemes were in use as some devices couldn't be renamed for reasons.
i dont even bother renaming them. WIN-P45GDSAS does the dns
oh and the domain is .local